Home » Blogs » Scant Reward From The Ups And Downs

Scant Reward From The Ups And Downs

Dual reg, uneven game format and medals or no medals bring it all to the fore

by Trevor Knell
0 comments

Whilst almost all the play-off games are now complete bar the National League top division and a few stragglers lurking about, attention will soon turn to whose going to end up where for next season.

Opinion on the ‘end of season party’ is mixed. They’ve been around for years in the professional game and in the National League since around 2004/05, more recently though introduced in Steps 5 and 6, the game not uniform all the way round or all the way down at the same time.

It has brought up a few talking points in the last weeks as well, dual registrations, extra time, straight to penalties, trophies and medals, no trophies and medals, there’s plenty to get into so let’s crack on.

Dual registration drama certainly filled up a few tweets just over a week ago in the play-off semi-finals. To clarify to begin with, there are absolutely no rules broken by sides at Step 5 and 6 adding Step 3 or 4 players at any point before the March deadline.

Morally, it doesn’t look good players coming in for a one off game replacing someone whose been at the sharp end for 30 odd games and missing out on the big one to clinch promotion. But managers are there to make unpopular decisions and win promotion at the same time, can you argue against it?

What I actually don’t like is players suspended at that higher level being allowed to play at the lower level, it’s no punishment being sent off if you can slot in elsewhere, that’s a big no and a loophole that needs to be shut off.

Serve your three game suspension, take the punishment and then try to win your place back, not keep up the fitness ready to go again at the higher level a few weeks after.

A few have suggested that these dual registered players should play a minimum amount of games to qualify for a club that reaches the play-offs. That might deter a few along the way, alternatively some will still find a way to make it fit somehow. My guess is that this would be the only way to have some kind of games marker, but I can’t imagine it ever coming into force.

Over the course of games at the same step levels there seems to be a different rule book for whatever league you seem to be playing in. Take away the National League from the equation and underneath we seem to be making it up as we go along. I watched two play off games from two different leagues over the last week, the first was going to penalties if it was level after 90 minutes.

The next one was level at 90 minutes, had extra time before penalties arrived, the difference? None, both games were at Step 5 so why not the same format? That’s a question I can’t answer, similar I saw happen at Step 4 so it really begs are the leagues able to control what happens instead of a rulebook that should be issued by the FA to cover all?

I mean, they don’t seem to have much else to do these things within the game so surely they can get something right at long last, or is that too much to really ask of the ‘governing’ body?

Whilst we’re on the subject of leagues controlling things, there seems to be another imbalance when it comes to the final. Again, two different leagues, one final with a trophy and medals and one without.

Granted it’s not a cup and it’s not a league title, but in effect it’s a small team tournament so should there not be a prize at the end of it? I mean, can you imagine the winners of the EFL final’s at Wembley not getting a trophy or medals to show for their efforts of winning?

That said league (or not mentioned in reality), I found out on Monday morning that two particular members of the board of the league were the ones stopping clubs and players receiving recognition, I mean how out of touch can you be of the competition you preside over, seemingly very.

Anyway, what do you think on any of the points raised in this one? Leave your notes in the comments, no right or wrong opinion, drop in anything else related or unrelated, it’s your articles to read after all…..

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?
-
00:00
00:00
Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00